Comparing an ESOP with a sale to an outside buyer?

An advisor with ESOP and sell-side experience can model both on an after-tax basis and tell you whether your company is a good ESOP candidate.

Find an Advisor

An employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) is a retirement plan that owns company stock on behalf of employees. When you sell to an ESOP, a trust set up by your company buys some or all of your shares at a price determined by an independent appraiser, usually with money borrowed from a bank, from you or both. Employees receive shares in their retirement accounts without paying for them, and you can keep working and ease out in stages if that suits you and the company (NCEO).

It is a real option for many profitable private companies, not a niche one. The National Center for Employee Ownership counts 6,098 privately held ESOPs in the U.S., based on 2023 filings, the latest available, with an average of about 269 new ESOPs created each year since 2019 (NCEO).

How does selling to an ESOP work?

  1. The company sets up an ESOP trust, which holds shares for employees and is governed by many of the same rules as a 401(k) plan (NCEO).
  2. The company borrows money, usually from a bank, a seller note or both, and lends it to the ESOP. That internal loan is usually repaid over 10 to 30 years (NCEO).
  3. The trust buys your shares at a price set by an independent appraisal.
  4. The company makes tax-deductible contributions to the ESOP, which uses them to repay the loan. Shares sit in a suspense account and are released to employee accounts as the loan is repaid.
  5. When employees retire or leave, the company buys back their shares at fair market value and pays them in cash (Congressional Research Service).

Because the money can come from a bank, the seller or both, you may end up financing part of your own buyout through a seller note. Our guide to seller financing covers how notes and subordination to a bank work.

How does an ESOP compare with selling to an outside buyer?

ESOPStrategic or private equity buyer
PriceCapped at fair market value set by an appraiserNegotiated; a strategic buyer may pay for synergies
How much you sellSome or all of the company, possibly in stagesUsually a controlling stake or all of it
Cash at closingDepends on how much the company can borrow; may include a seller noteOften most of the price, depending on the buyer
Tax benefitsPossible Section 1042 deferral (C corporations); S corporation ESOP tax exemptionStandard sale treatment
Your role after the saleYou can stay involved and transition graduallyDepends on the buyer
Employees and cultureEmployees become beneficial owners; company stays independentMay be integrated or kept intact
ConfidentialityNo competing bidders reviewing your booksCompetitors may see sensitive data in diligence

See our comparison of private equity and strategic buyers for how outside offers are usually structured.

What are the tax benefits?

For C corporation owners: the Section 1042 rollover. Under federal tax law, you can elect to defer tax on gain from selling shares to an ESOP if (26 U.S.C. 1042; NCEO):

  • The company is a domestic C corporation with no publicly traded stock
  • The ESOP owns at least 30% of the company immediately after the sale
  • You have held the shares for at least three years
  • You reinvest the proceeds in qualified replacement property (generally stocks and bonds of U.S. operating companies) within a window running from three months before to 12 months after the sale

Law firm Bond, Schoeneck & King notes that if the replacement securities are held until death, the deferral can become permanent (BSK).

For S corporation owners: a different benefit. S corporation sellers generally can’t use the 1042 rollover today. A 2022 amendment allows an election covering no more than 10% of the amount realized on S corporation stock, for sales after December 31, 2027 (26 U.S.C. 1042). But once an ESOP owns S corporation shares, the income attributable to the ESOP’s ownership is not subject to federal income tax, and a 100% ESOP-owned S corporation pays no federal income tax (BSK). That can free up cash to repay acquisition debt faster.

For the company: contributions used to repay the ESOP loan are tax-deductible, subject to limits (NCEO; BSK).

These rules are detailed and change over time. Work through them with a tax advisor who handles ESOP transactions before you decide.

What are the downsides?

  • No premium above fair market value. An ESOP transaction is exempt from ERISA’s prohibited-transaction rules only if it happens at fair market value (“adequate consideration”). A strategic buyer may be willing to pay more (CRS).
  • Less cash up front. The price is limited by how much debt the company can carry, so part of your proceeds may come later through a seller note.
  • Ongoing obligations. The company must buy back shares from departing employees, which needs planning and cash (CRS).
  • Regulation and scrutiny. ESOPs are retirement plans governed by ERISA. The plan’s trustee or named fiduciary must determine the stock’s value in good faith, and CRS notes that the owner’s usual role in choosing the appraiser can raise conflict-of-interest concerns.
  • Not every company fits. The company needs steady earnings to service the debt and management that can run the business after you step back. BSK recommends a feasibility study before pursuing a leveraged ESOP.

Is an ESOP right for your business?

An ESOP is worth a serious look if your company is consistently profitable, you have a capable management team, you care about keeping the business independent and rewarding employees, and you are open to a gradual exit. It is less likely to fit if you need the highest possible cash price at closing or a strategic buyer could pay well above fair market value.

Many owners compare both paths before deciding. An advisor can run a valuation and model an ESOP against outside offers on an after-tax basis. For example, Prairie Capital Advisors, one of the firms listed in our directory, offers ESOP advisory alongside investment banking and describes a process for evaluating an M&A sale and an ESOP buyout at the same time. This article is general information, not tax, legal or investment advice; confirm the details with your own advisors. To find firms that work at your deal size, browse the Top 100 M&A advisors or find an advisor.

FAQ

Common questions

How does a business owner sell to an ESOP?
The company sets up an ESOP trust. The trust buys some or all of the owner's shares, usually with money the company borrows from a bank, the seller or both. The company then makes tax-deductible contributions that the trust uses to repay the loan, and shares are allocated to employees' retirement accounts as the debt is paid down. Employees don't pay for the shares.
Will an ESOP pay as much as an outside buyer?
Not necessarily. An ESOP can pay no more than fair market value as determined by an appraiser. A strategic buyer that can capture synergies may be willing to pay more than that. Tax benefits can narrow or close the gap, so it makes sense to compare offers on an after-tax basis.
What is a Section 1042 rollover?
It lets an owner of a closely held C corporation defer federal tax on gain from selling shares to an ESOP, if the ESOP owns at least 30% of the company after the sale, the owner has held the shares for at least three years, and the proceeds are reinvested in qualified replacement property (stocks and bonds of U.S. operating companies) between three months before and 12 months after the sale.
Can S corporation owners use the 1042 rollover?
Generally not for sales today. A 2022 law change allows an election for S corporation stock covering no more than 10% of the amount realized, for sales after December 31, 2027. S corporations that are owned by an ESOP have a different benefit: income attributable to the ESOP's ownership is not subject to federal income tax.
Do I have to sell 100% of my company to an ESOP?
No. An ESOP can buy part of the company, and owners can sell in stages over time. Note that the 1042 rollover requires the ESOP to own at least 30% after the sale.
Related Reading

Keep learning

Find An Advisor

Comparing an ESOP with a sale to an outside buyer?

An advisor with ESOP and sell-side experience can model both on an after-tax basis and tell you whether your company is a good ESOP candidate.